Monday, August 18, 2008

Where is the zing Mr.Kinng?

Off late, the Hindi Cinema is all about making big bucks. Get a star worth crores, a director who’s had a hit or two, location shoot in the exotic foreign locales; go far out to the maximum extent with the publicity. And you’ve got the initial audience. Unless your luck is really as bad as Yashraj’s ‘Tashan’, it’s a winner formula.

The opening disclaimer in ‘Singh is Kinng’ included lines to the effect that, ‘The hen in the hen chase scene is digitally crafted; no cruelty has been imposed on animals for the shoot of that scene’. Uhh…what about the cruelty inflicted upon us the humans who watched this tripe in the name of ‘mass entertainment’?

I understand that all filmmakers don’t want to change the world - they don’t want to make message movies, they probably don’t want to address issues either. I get that. But how can a filmmaker not care about engaging his viewer - how can he not care if his audience is entertained or not? If you’re making what you describe as a comedy, shouldn’t you want the audience to laugh? ‘Singh Is Kinng’ is a film that has little or no regard for its audience. They only care about the fact that you paid your hundred bucks and bought your ticket! I know that people who make films shouldn’t be made to feel guilty about wanting to earn money from them - I agree with that completely. My problem is with people whose only objective for making films is to make money - they could well be in the construction business, they could be manufacturing cigarettes, but they are making movies for a living!

In a recent interview, director Anees Bazmi said ‘My basic aim is that the film is a big hit, people make a lot of money, actors can raise their fees and everybody else gets paid more. Maybe 10 critics will write bad things but the lives of 100 people will change’. I do hope the makers can afford swanky new BMWs from the money this film will invariably make. Someone should get something from this film, because the audience gets nothing! ‘Singh is Kinng’ is a pedestrian film. There isn’t a flash of wit or elegance in it.

None of Akshay Kumar’s commercially successful capers of late, I suspect, are likely to be worshipped in public memory. Yet each, regardless of everything else, has packed in theaters with sustained publicity and quite literally brought in the moolah. The last few I've had the misfortune of sitting through were called Namastey London, Bhool Bhulaiya, Welcome, and all supposed super-hits! Now, ‘Singh is Kinng’ adds to this long list.

The story of ‘Singh is Kinng’ is a taken from the highly successful Jackie Chan starrer ‘Mr. Canton and Lady Rose’ a film through which Jackie Chan paid tribute to the American Director Frank Capra. The thing to admire here is that now a days our sources for films have become more exotic - since we’ve already extensively ripped off Hollywood, we are now cannibalizing other cinemas of the world!

Whoz ugly and whoz pagli?

‘Yeh Bambai hai. Yahan par sabke paas script hai. Doodhwale se leker Bhansali tak’. This is a line that a peon rudely tells Ranvir Shorey when he goes to sell his girlfriend’s script to a production house. But, obviously the director Sachin Kamalakar when making this film didn’t have a script because ‘Ugly aur Pagli’ is a poor & ugly copy of Korean classic ‘My Sassy Girl’ which was adapted from a young man’s true-life experiences posted on the Internet.

Sachin Kamalakar should have kept in mind that mere copying a film does not work; the basic problem is that the screenplay rewritten to Indian conditions is patently absurd and mind-scrambling. Incidentally, quiet a few scenes from ‘My Sassy Girl’ were earlier lifted in Yashraj’s mind-numbing ‘Neal N Nikki’.

Since the film is a romantic comedy, the director tries very very hard to make the movie differently funny, but the gags fall flat, the humour has few, very few clever one liners!

Individual performances are quite good. To a large extent in the film Mallika Sherawat rocks as the domineering, sharp-tongued woman until she starts crying and Ranvir Shorey polishes his loser act to perfection and manages to rise over the script on most occasions. Cameos by Bharati Achrekar and Sushmita Mukherjee are fun. And I wish that Zeenat Aman hadn't been wasted in a one scene appearance!

Watch the original Korean classic, anyday. Its one of my all time favourite romantic comedies.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Rajinikanth's much hyped film fails to live up to the expectations!

‘Kathanayakudu’ is a remake of the hit Malayalam film ‘Katha Parayambol’ a modern take on the Krishna-Sudama story, with an obvious twist. It could have been a simple and unsophisticated story with a touching theme of friendship. But what it ends up is being raw, loud and missing all that little moments that the movie needs. While the title has been chosen keeping the Super Star status of Rajnikanth and his crowd pulling capacity, the film is essentially about Jagapathi Babu.

Something similar to a debate from ‘A film by Arvind’, in one of the scenes from the film, Rajnikanth meditates on who really a Super Star is - is it the individual or the individuals who write the script and the characters. Rajnikanth gives the credit to all his writers who worked with him and hails them as the real Super Stars. At another point in the film, Rajnikanth says that if the story is not good, then even the Super Star cannot save it. Unfortunately, the Super Star does not succeed in striking a chord with the audience with ‘Kathanayakudu’. The film absolutely lacks believability, and the makers look in to pull off some extra gags by painfully injecting re-enactments from Rajni’s best box-office blockbusters like ‘Narsimha’, ‘Chandramukhi’, and so on. Apparently, these scenes are for their sequels, which makes one wonder how many movies is the Super Star shooting for or is it a film titled ‘Best-of-Rajni’?

Nayantara sizzles in the same i-really-wanna-be-a-bad-girl mood. Meena is just about ok in a brief role. Mamta Mohandas clearly is in the pits of her career to have accepted such a blink and miss role which only lasts for a couple of shots! Prabhu is painfully obese. In fact, our Union Minister for Health A. Ramdoss can use Prabhu for a National Public Health Campaign to show how one will eventually look like with a junkie-sedentary lifestyle. Rajnikanth is his usual self. Poor chap, what could he do having being caught with his own philosphy? With no story, even the superstar can do nothing! The saving grace of the film is Jagapathi Babu who comes up with a brilliant performance.

The director, who had earlier made ‘Chandramukhi’ is completely out of form here. Moved by the original, he has quickly roped in Rajnikanth and shot a hotch-potch film that doesn’t even fit with the theme or the concept of the story! Yes, there will be tears at the end, but that is only because Rajnikanth sheds tears in a well enacted emotional scene. The friendship connection and depth in the screenplay is missing even as the Director is totally out of ideas as to how-to-show Rajnikanth in a new and innovative style - Zorro, 007, Pharoh etc… I didn’t even understand why that irrelevant solo-song in the rain with Nayantara in a skimpy two piece? Didn’t the Director have the confidence in his film and even the Super Star Rajnikanth that he felt he needed a wet and gyrating Nayantara to pull in the crowds?!? The only person who would have enjoyed this song would be the cameraman who was all over Nayantara’s body. The writing is mediocre. The music is just about ok. The village set looks very artificial. It is supposed to be an Indian village but it looks more like a set from a cowboy film in Hollywood!

This movie had all the potential to be simple and beautiful but Rajinikanth’s much hyped ‘Kathanayakudu’ fails to live up to the expectations. Let's hope for Shahrukh Khan's sake his ‘Billoo Barber’ turns out to be a more purposeful and entertaining film.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Mission Turkey!

Please put your hands together to felicitate the one and only Apoorva Lakhia for making the worst film of the year so far – Mission Istanbul. This one's a Turkey if there ever was one, and to relish it, you've got to be in the mood for Christmas!

To put it mildly, ‘Mission Istanbul’ is ‘Murder of Cinema’ and I am sure the future generations of film students could write several theses on this murder. It has such a cruelly contrived story that you wonder if the writers of the script are truly in touch with the real world. Guess what! Al Qaeda roams free in Kabul post the American invasion of Afghanistan and the public killings still take place in football stadiums under the rule of the new Afghan government. Not just this, Northern Alliance is still fighting its battle with Al Qaeda. I truly feared that the Director would next show Ahmed Shah Masood alive and kicking the sh*t out of Al Qaeda. Thankfully, that didn’t happen!

The film could have made interesting points about the economics of terror, the commoditization of news and its sensationalized packaging as entertainment. It also alludes to various vested Western interests in keeping the region in conflict but takes that thread nowhere. Sequences, set pieces and plot devices are liberally sourced from Hollywood fare such as Enemy of the State, The Siege, The Matrix, Swordfish and the Hong Kong actioner Infernal Affairs. The rest apparently came from the fertile imaginations of the director and writer. One of which would be the blatant product and tagline placement for a fizzy drink (Mountain Dew) done so horribly badly that I, for one, am never going to be able to pick up a can of that stuff again!

Vivek Oberoi opts for a knowing smirk while Zayed Khan looks like he's barely able to control his steroid rage. No opportunity to overact is missed by either of them. Shabbir Ahluwalia and Nikitin Dheer are no better. Shriya Saran constantly looks like she's straining to remember her lines (or she's smelt something unpleasant) while Shweta Bhardwaj's simpering appears better suited for ads in the back pages of certain guy magazines.

Apoorva Lakhia’s (one of the most overrated Directors in Bollywood) style of filmmaking is to take stylish shots and put them in quick succession to each other and add the remaining impact by loud background music. He really needs to work as an assistant under some truly qualified director to get the basics right. This is the same movie that was offered to Apoorva Lakhia, with the accompanying fat pay cheque, it was not money well spent for the producers Suniel Shetty & Ekta Kapoor.

There are so many flaws in the film that one can keep on writing….. The true heros of the film are the audience who brave sitting through this ‘Mission Turkey’. And before this piece becomes even more incoherent than it already is, I must sign off and attempt to undo the brain damage. Let's just hope Apoorva Lakhia doesn't decide to make a sequel and call it MI:2 as he has already compared this ‘Mission Turkey’ to ‘Mission Impossible’ in one of his interviews!

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Umar sari toh kati ishqe butta mein momin. Aakhri waqt mein kya khaq Musalman hogaye?

The loose translation of the above Urdu couplet by legendary poet Momin Khan would be: All your life you lived in non-Muslim ways. In your old age, how can you become a Muslim? For me this couplet quiet sums up Khuda Ke Liye – In the Name of God.

I’ve been reading a lot about Khuda Ke Liye – first Pakistani movie to release in India after 43 years, a movie that has become a craze all over Pakistan, so much so, that on one hand there was a fatwa against it by some radical maulvis and on the other hand an endorsement from Pervez Musharraf, the director of the movie went on vacation with his family, as soon as the movie was released fearing his life, the film was recently honoured with Pakistan's highest civilian award Sitar-i-Imtiaz, etc.., I was very curious to watch Khuda Ke Liye and since I had missed it when it released in India a few months ago, I decided to buy the DVD of the film.

I remember getting bowled over by Pakistani director Sabiha Sumer’s excellent film Khamosh Pani a couple of years ago when it was shown at the MAMI festival. Khamosh Pani told the story of a youth in rural Pakistan who falls under the influence of fundamentalists, and turns his back to his mother and his lover.

Writer / Director Shoaib Mansoor’s movie Khuda Ke Liye – In the name of God goes a step further. The story is interesting as it handles two major issues – religious extremism and racial profiling - and twines them well. There are other issues also that the movie tries to focus on; condition of women during Taliban days in Afghanistan, theological issues of acceptance of music and cultural contextualization of Islam and the way various groups are putting forward their own version of the religion. The film’s introspective theme also takes a look within the contemporary Pakistani society and shows the wedge between the moderates and extremists, it also brings to the fore the less-acknowledged truth that Muslims are being viewed with increasing suspicion in the West. All it takes for you to become a terror suspect is be a Muslim, even though a progressive and moderate one. Besides this, the film also highlights the double standards in the largely patriarchal Pakistani Muslim society where women have to follow what men decide for them, even against their wishes.

Loaded with such relevant issues Khuda Ke Liye turns out to be a film that not just entertains you, but it raises questions in your mind about the denigration and hypocrisy in our society and religion. The movie also attempts to take on the raging debates consuming the Muslim World and Muslims living in foreign lands. The story starts somewhere in pre 9/11 timeframe and ends in late 2002 in the midst of which it follows various characters facing an array of issues in life.

It is a heart wrenching film with good performances by all the actors Shaan, Fawad Khan, Iman Ali and Naseeruddin Shah, who has a cameo in the film and not surprisingly a very powerful one. The film’s music and songs are mesmerizing, particularly 'Allah Ho' and ‘Bandeya’.

Khuda Ke Liye is a brilliant movie, especially if you are interested in what Islam has to say on various issues. Shoaib Mansoor deserves kudos because he tackles a bold and controversial theme that attacks Islamic fundamentalism in a subtle way and that too, in Pakistan. With honest intentions, deft handling of a serious, sensitive and pertinent subject Shoaib Mansoor has done a creditable job as Writer / Director.

A theme like the one depicted in Khuda Ke Liye – In the Name of God is more for the thinking viewer, who loves to ponder over the movie after watching it.